ILLINOIS FOCUS. A NATIONWIDE ADVISORY TEAM.Jason Taken · HedgeStone Business Advisors

VALUATION & FINANCING / THE RESTAURANT DEAL FIELD GUIDE

How do delivery commissions change restaurant SDE?

Delivery commissions affect the cost of generating channel revenue, but their presentation may differ between reports. Reconcile gross orders, revenue adjustments, commissions, promotions, and payouts before recasting earnings. Include necessary packaging, labor, and recurring channel costs. Do not add back a fee already netted from sales or treat recurring delivery expense as automatically discretionary.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Net platform payouts are cash settlements rather than a complete revenue-and-expense presentation.
  • A gross-to-net bridge prevents omitted or duplicated delivery commissions.
  • Channel contribution must include the actual incremental operating costs.
  • Buyer-specific pricing changes belong in a separate forecast from historical SDE.

Which delivery numbers are being compared?

Identify gross menu orders, refunds, discounts, promotions, sales tax, tips, commissions, other charges, recognized revenue, and bank settlements. Reports can group these differently. A dashboard total, accounting line, tax return, and deposit are not automatically the same measurement.

Use the same period and explain cutoffs. Late settlements, refunds for earlier orders, promotion adjustments, or different report dates can create differences without proving missing sales. Conversely, a plausible timing explanation still needs supporting records.

The valuation hub frames restaurant earnings analysis. Start the delivery review with a source-based bridge rather than a debate about which headline total looks more favorable to the seller or buyer.

What records support the gross-to-net reconciliation?

Obtain platform statements and exports, merchant agreements, point-of-sale reports, bank deposits, ledger entries, invoices, promotion records, and relevant tax support. Identify which entity, store, account, and channel each record covers.

The IRS recordkeeping guidance supports evidence for income and expenses. Acquisition diligence additionally needs the relationship between the channel activity and the reported profit. A screenshot showing orders cannot establish commissions, refunds, or the cash actually received.

The POS-verification definition explains broader reconciliation principles. Ensure an integrated order is not counted once in the platform and again as separate point-of-sale revenue. The systems may describe the same transaction rather than two sales.

How does an illustrative delivery bridge work?

Assume fictional menu orders of $100,000 for a defined period, excluding sales tax and tips in this simplified example. Refunds are $2,400, producing $97,600 after that adjustment. Assumed commissions are $24,400 and merchant-funded promotions are $4,800, leaving $68,400 before other items under this stated illustration.

The CPA must determine actual accounting classification and treatment. The example’s labels do not establish how every contract or tax return should report the amounts. The purpose is to make the components visible and reconcile them consistently.

If $68,400 appears as net revenue in one management report, do not automatically add $24,400 commissions to earnings while leaving revenue net. A gross presentation and a net presentation can reach consistent profit only when the associated amounts are handled correctly and nothing is omitted or counted twice.

Which delivery costs belong in channel contribution?

Delivery-channel earnings reconciliation
ComponentSource evidenceQuestion for recast earnings
Orders and adjustmentsTransaction-level statementsWhat revenue measure is supported?
Commissions and chargesActual statements and termsAre fees expensed, netted, or omitted?
PromotionsMerchant-funded campaign recordsWhat cost supported the observed sales?
PackagingPurchases, usage, and inventoryWhat recurring cost serves these orders?
FoodMenu costing and purchasing evidenceWhat product cost is attributable?
Labor and capacitySchedules and operating analysisWhat work and displacement occur?
SettlementBank reconciliation and timing bridgeDoes cash match the explained activity?

Distinguish direct channel costs from allocated fixed costs and buyer changes. An allocation can help compare channels, but it should not invent a saving that would not occur if the restaurant reduced delivery orders.

What remains after packaging, labor, and food?

Continue the hypothetical example with $3,900 packaging, $14,600 defined delivery-related labor, and $30,256 food cost. Starting from the stated $68,400 after refunds, commissions, and promotions, those additional costs leave $19,644 before other fixed expenses, financing, tax, capital needs, and further adjustments.

The invented food cost happens to equal 31% of the example’s $97,600 adjusted amount. It is not an industry benchmark. Actual ingredient usage, waste, menu mix, purchasing, and labor need evidence rather than a convenient standard percentage.

The IRS small-business publication discusses inventories and cost of goods sold. Have the CPA reconcile the actual reporting and avoid confusing a contribution illustration with a complete financial statement or tax calculation.

When is a commission adjustment double counted?

Trace the fee through every report used in the earnings bridge. It may already reduce displayed revenue, appear as an operating expense, be combined with merchant charges, or be omitted from an incomplete statement. The recast must fix presentation without manufacturing profit.

For example, a seller who starts with a net settlement-based revenue number cannot remove the fee again from expenses that were never deducted there. Likewise, a gross-sales report that omits the corresponding commission can overstate earnings until the actual cost is included.

IRS Publication 538 addresses accounting-method principles. The CPA should review actual contracts, classifications, and timing. A presentation correction should have an explainable effect, including no change to profit when it simply moves the same supported amounts between gross and net lines.

Why are recurring delivery fees usually part of operating economics?

If the presented restaurant relies on a delivery channel under actual terms, the necessary channel costs are part of the business model. Calling a fee frustrating, high, or negotiable does not establish that it is nonrecurring or discretionary.

The SDE definition explains the need for supportable adjustments. A one-time correction or different fact may warrant analysis, but document it separately rather than remove every platform charge to improve the asking-price narrative.

Ask what happens to orders if the channel is removed. A seller cannot normally retain all associated revenue while deleting its cost without evidence. A buyer’s independent ordering plan is a separate strategy with its own marketing, payment, support, and fulfillment expenses.

How should buyer-specific fee changes be shown?

Obtain actual proposed terms and explain which approval, migration, volume, product, or other conditions remain. The DoorDash merchant FAQ provides platform context, but current agreements and the actual store setup need confirmation. Do not assume every buyer inherits a historical rate or feature.

The delivery-account guide addresses rights and transition. A lower forecast fee can improve modeled contribution while introducing setup, migration, customer-retention, and execution questions.

Keep three schedules: verified historical results, normalized results with supported adjustments, and the buyer forecast. That separation lets advisers and lenders evaluate assumptions without confusing an opportunity with earnings already generated by the seller.

What operational questions can change contribution?

Review kitchen capacity, peak periods, order accuracy, packaging, staffing, refunds, customer experience, and displacement of profitable dining trade. An order that looks incremental in a dashboard may compete for constrained labor or equipment during the busiest service period.

Evaluate promotions using contribution after actual costs rather than total orders acquired. A discount can increase revenue while leaving little incremental cash. Document the campaign period, expense, results, and continuing assumptions before treating the effect as a permanent improvement.

The prime-cost definition helps connect food and labor analysis. Do not assign every shared cost arbitrarily to delivery, but do not ignore real work simply because payroll is already paid elsewhere in the restaurant.

What should the CPA and transaction team review?

Ask the CPA to reconcile classifications, periods, gross versus net presentation, tax and tip treatment, inventory, payroll allocation, and adjustments. Have counsel review actual merchant terms, account rights, disclosure, and permitted transfer or onboarding procedures.

Identify unresolved material items before price and financing decisions. A buyer should understand the supported channel economics and the terms needed to continue operations, rather than rely on a percentage of gross sales as proof of value.

Which mistakes should the parties prevent?

  1. Treating bank settlements as the complete sales-and-cost story.
  2. Counting integrated platform orders twice.
  3. Adding back commissions already netted from revenue.
  4. Removing recurring fees while retaining all associated sales.
  5. Ignoring packaging, labor, promotions, and capacity effects.
  6. Presenting a buyer’s proposed fee savings as historical seller earnings.

A useful delivery recast preserves the relationship between revenue, cost, and cash. The resulting SDE discussion becomes supportable when each adjustment has evidence and the buyer’s future strategy remains clearly identified as a forecast.

What else do owners and buyers ask?

Are delivery commissions a valid seller add-back?

Not merely because the seller considers them expensive or believes a buyer could negotiate better terms. Determine whether the expense is recurring and necessary under the business being presented, and whether it is already netted from revenue. Any proposed adjustment needs source evidence, a stated rationale, and consistent treatment reviewed by the CPA.

Should restaurant delivery sales be reported gross or net?

The correct financial and tax presentation requires the actual arrangements, accounting method, and professional review. For diligence, build a clear bridge between gross orders, adjustments, fees, and cash settlements regardless of the report format. Do not compare inconsistent totals or assume bank deposits alone show the complete economics of the channel.

Can higher delivery sales lower SDE?

Additional orders can contribute less than expected, or consume cash, when commissions, promotions, packaging, food, labor, refunds, and capacity costs exceed their incremental benefit. Evaluate the actual contribution and impact on other channels. Gross revenue growth alone does not establish improved owner earnings, particularly when discounts or operational disruption accompany the increase.

Can the buyer assume the seller’s delivery fee plan will continue?

Verify the actual merchant agreement, platform process, ownership change, pricing, products, and intended configuration. Do not promise continued terms from a historical statement or seller assurance. Show supported buyer-specific changes separately from past results, and assess migration, rights, timing, and operating consequences before treating the channel as unchanged after closing.

Where can you verify the details?

Primary sources reviewed for this guide. Requirements can change; confirm the rules that apply to your address and transaction.

  1. Recordkeeping for your business — Internal Revenue Service
  2. Publication 538: accounting periods and methods — Internal Revenue Service
  3. Publication 334: inventories and cost of goods sold — Internal Revenue Service
  4. Merchant frequently asked questions — DoorDash

Return to valuation & financing

YOUR NEXT CHAPTER STARTS WITH A CONVERSATION

Let’s talk about
your restaurant.

Buying, selling, or weighing your options? Bring your questions. We’ll help you think through the next step.

Book a confidential intro call
Book a confidential intro call