ILLINOIS FOCUS. A NATIONWIDE ADVISORY TEAM.Jason Taken · HedgeStone Business Advisors

BUYING A RESTAURANT / THE RESTAURANT DEAL FIELD GUIDE

How do buyers evaluate a restaurant with a percentage-rent lease?

Read the actual formula and gross-sales definition before modeling percentage rent. Reconcile base rent, breakpoints, included channels, exclusions, timing, reporting, audit provisions, and other occupancy charges. Test both lower and higher sales using the same contract assumptions, and verify historical payments rather than assume rent is a fixed percentage of reported restaurant revenue.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Percentage rent and total occupancy cost are different measurements.
  • A breakpoint stated in the lease may differ from a calculated natural breakpoint.
  • Delivery, catering, taxes, refunds, tips, and other amounts need actual definition review.
  • Higher sales can trigger additional rent while lower sales leave base obligations unchanged.

What does the percentage-rent clause actually require?

Obtain the complete lease, amendments, rent schedules, sales-reporting provisions, notices, and relevant correspondence. Identify base rent, percentage rate, breakpoint, calculation period, payment timing, reconciliation, exclusions, audit provisions, and any caps or other negotiated terms.

Do not rely on a listing description that says rent is six percent of sales. That phrase might omit minimum base rent, a threshold, other charges, reporting definitions, or a different formula. Counsel should interpret the actual agreement before the buyer or CPA builds the financial model.

The buyer hub covers the wider acquisition. The rent-to-sales definition explains a financial ratio, which is different from the contractual formula determining what the tenant owes.

What counts as sales under this lease?

Create a contract-to-accounting bridge. Review treatment of dining, delivery, catering, private events, off-site activity, related operations, tax, tips, refunds, discounts, gift cards, service charges, and other items relevant to the actual restaurant. The agreement may define these differently from management reports.

The IRS recordkeeping guidance supports underlying financial evidence. It does not define gross sales for every private lease. Use the contract and legal advice to determine the relevant measure, then obtain the records needed to calculate it.

For delivery platforms, distinguish gross orders from commissions and net settlements. The delivery-account guide explains reconciliation issues that can also affect lease reporting. Do not assume net bank deposits are the correct sales base merely because they are easy to obtain.

What is a natural breakpoint, and why might it not control?

In a simplified calculation, annual base rent divided by the percentage rate produces a natural breakpoint. For example, an invented $84,000 annual base rent divided by 6% equals $1,400,000. That arithmetic does not establish that the actual lease uses this threshold.

A lease can state a different breakpoint, a different period, or another structure. Have counsel and the CPA identify the operative formula and definitions. Do not replace a negotiated threshold with a calculated natural breakpoint because the latter appears more familiar.

The Counselors of Real Estate lease-transfer discussion reinforces the importance of actual lease terms in transactions. Percentage-rent economics need the same document-based discipline as assignment, use, and other premises obligations.

What should the percentage-rent review dashboard contain?

Percentage-rent acquisition diligence
IssueEvidence to obtainModeling consequence
Base rentCurrent schedule, increases, and concessionsMinimum recurring obligation
BreakpointExact threshold and calculation periodWhen additional rent begins
Sales definitionIncluded channels and exclusionsRevenue measure used in the formula
Percentage rateActual clause and any tiersIncremental rent as sales change
ReportingFrequency, format, and certificationsAdministrative duties and timing
Audit rightsAccess, records, dispute, and cost provisionsExposure to later adjustments
Other occupancy costsTaxes, insurance, maintenance, and chargesTotal premises cash burden

Add unresolved items and the adviser responsible for each. The dashboard should expose contract and evidence gaps rather than present an unverified spreadsheet as a definitive rent opinion.

How does the formula work in a hypothetical acquisition?

Assume a fictional lease requires $84,000 annual base rent plus 6% of defined annual sales above a stated $1,200,000 threshold. If defined sales are $1,400,000, excess sales are $200,000 and additional rent is $12,000. Total base and percentage rent would be $96,000.

That is about 6.86% of $1,400,000, not simply the 6% stated rate. If other stated occupancy charges are $36,000 annually, the combined amount becomes $132,000, or about 9.43% of those sales.

These numbers are invented and use a simplified formula. They are not market terms, a safe occupancy ratio, or legal interpretation. Apply the actual lease definitions, timing, and accounting with professional review before relying on any calculation.

What happens in lower-sales and growth scenarios?

Under the same hypothetical clause, $900,000 defined sales would not produce additional percentage rent, but the $84,000 base remains. Base rent alone would then equal about 9.33% of sales, before the other occupancy charges. Reduced sales have not reduced every premises obligation.

At $1,700,000 defined sales, the modeled excess over $1,200,000 is $500,000, producing $30,000 additional rent and $114,000 base-plus-percentage rent. The buyer should include that incremental cost when evaluating growth contribution rather than treat all added sales as available profit.

Model food, labor, delivery, marketing, and capacity costs alongside rent. A higher-sales forecast can improve cash while also requiring more working capital and additional premises payments. The formula is one component of a complete operating model.

How should historical rent payments be verified?

Obtain landlord statements, tenant sales reports, payment evidence, reconciliations, audit correspondence, credits, and disputes for relevant periods. Tie the reported sales measure to supported operating records and explain differences in timing or definitions.

IRS Publication 538 addresses accounting methods and timing principles. The private lease’s reporting requirement still needs separate interpretation. A cash-basis management line or tax treatment does not automatically determine when rent becomes due under the contract.

The landlord estoppel guide can help organize confirmation of actual rent, adjustments, and unresolved notices. A signed confirmation should be reconciled to source documents and not treated as an automatic release of every potential issue.

How can percentage rent affect valuation and financing?

Reconcile historical earnings using the rent actually attributable under the reviewed assumptions. Identify arrears, one-time corrections, concessions, and recurring payments. Do not remove a necessary percentage-rent expense as a seller add-back merely because it varies with sales.

The valuation hub supports separating transferable business economics from buyer-specific growth plans. A buyer anticipating more sales should model the resulting occupancy cost rather than capitalize gross growth without the additional rent.

Give the lender the full lease and consistent forecast. Financing eligibility and underwriting require the actual borrower, transaction, premises, and current rules. No particular rate, breakpoint, or lease description guarantees approval or establishes an affordable debt burden.

Which reporting and audit obligations deserve attention?

Identify required reports, signatures, records access, retention, deadlines, confidentiality, dispute procedures, and potential cost provisions. Have counsel review the actual language and the CPA assess whether the restaurant’s systems can produce the required information reliably.

Plan lawful handling of sensitive customer, employee, and financial data if audits or disclosures occur. Providing relevant support does not mean unrestricted access to unrelated records. Clarify rights and processes before a dispute rather than invent them after an audit request arrives.

Maintain consistent reports and preserve the evidence behind adjustments. If the buyer changes point-of-sale, delivery, or accounting systems, ensure the contractual sales measure remains traceable across the transition instead of losing the ability to reconcile periods.

What changes during a business transfer?

The lease-assignment definition explains why consent, assumption, amendment, and seller release are distinct. Determine which party handles pre-closing sales reports, later reconciliations, audit claims, and payments related to periods spanning closing.

Have counsel align the purchase agreement and lease documents. A private buyer-seller allocation does not automatically alter the landlord’s rights. The closing model should account for unresolved amounts and avoid charging the same historical adjustment twice.

Which mistakes should the buyer avoid?

  1. Treating the stated percentage as total occupancy cost.
  2. Substituting a natural breakpoint for the contract’s actual threshold.
  3. Using net delivery deposits without reviewing the sales definition.
  4. Assuming lower sales reduce minimum base rent proportionally.
  5. Forecasting growth without its additional rent and operating costs.
  6. Ignoring reporting, audit, and pre-closing reconciliation obligations.

A workable analysis ties the exact clause to verified records and a buyer-specific cash model. That makes both downside exposure and growth economics visible before price, financing, and premises commitments become final.

What else do owners and buyers ask?

What is a restaurant percentage-rent breakpoint?

It is the sales threshold used under the actual lease formula to determine additional rent. Some discussions use a natural breakpoint calculated from base rent and the percentage rate, but a contract may specify another threshold or structure. Counsel and the CPA should review the exact definition, period, and calculation rather than assume a universal method.

Are delivery-platform sales included in percentage rent?

Read the actual lease definition, exclusions, channel terms, and amendments with counsel. Gross orders, recognized revenue, and net platform payouts are different measures, and the contract may address them specifically. Reconcile the relevant records and do not assume commissions automatically reduce reportable sales or that off-premises orders are always excluded.

Does percentage rent protect me when sales fall?

Additional percentage rent may decrease under the formula, but base rent, pass-through charges, repairs, and other obligations can remain. Model the actual lease rather than assume rent falls proportionally with revenue. A lower-sales scenario can produce a higher occupancy burden as a share of sales even when no percentage payment is due.

Can I use last year’s rent expense for my acquisition forecast?

Use historical payments as evidence, then reconcile the formula, reporting period, adjustments, arrears, escalations, concessions, and proposed changes. Your sales mix and volume may differ from the seller’s. Build a buyer-specific forecast and have advisers review disputed or unresolved amounts rather than assume one historical expense line remains correct indefinitely.

Where can you verify the details?

Primary sources reviewed for this guide. Requirements can change; confirm the rules that apply to your address and transaction.

  1. Leases: a ticking time bomb in your company’s merger? — Counselors of Real Estate
  2. Recordkeeping for your business — Internal Revenue Service
  3. Publication 538: accounting periods and methods — Internal Revenue Service

Return to buying a restaurant

YOUR NEXT CHAPTER STARTS WITH A CONVERSATION

Let’s talk about
your restaurant.

Buying, selling, or weighing your options? Bring your questions. We’ll help you think through the next step.

Book a confidential intro call
Book a confidential intro call