ILLINOIS FOCUS. A NATIONWIDE ADVISORY TEAM.Jason Taken · HedgeStone Business Advisors

VALUATION & FINANCING / THE RESTAURANT DEAL FIELD GUIDE

The Four-Number Restaurant Screen: an early deal reality check

The Four-Number Restaurant Screen is Illinois Restaurant Broker's initial planning framework: examine verified earnings, occupancy cost, owner replacement cost, and cash after closing. Together, these figures reveal whether the apparent opportunity deserves further diligence. The screen is a discussion tool, not an appraisal, lender underwriting standard, investment recommendation, or substitute for examining the underlying records.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Use the same period and consistent definitions for all four numbers; leave unverified figures visibly unresolved.
  • Calculate owner replacement for the buyer's intended role rather than assuming the seller's labor disappears without cost.
  • Include project costs and reserves when calculating cash after closing, and separate that cash from the seller's sale proceeds.

What is the purpose of this screen?

The purpose is to expose mismatches before a buyer or seller becomes attached to a headline price. A restaurant can report attractive owner benefit while leaving a successor with expensive occupancy, substantial management needs, and too little cash to operate.

The Four-Number Restaurant Screen is a four-part review of verified earnings, occupancy cost, owner replacement cost, and buyer cash remaining after the full acquisition project is funded.

This is an original editorial framework from Illinois Restaurant Broker. It creates a common conversation between an owner, buyer, and adviser. It does not assign a standardized credit grade or determine whether a bank must approve a loan. Start with the valuation hub for the distinction between price, value, financing capacity, and proceeds, then use the screen to organize your evidence.

How do you establish verified earnings?

Trace earnings back to revenue and expenses that can be reconciled for the same period. Request financial statements, tax returns, POS data, processor statements, delivery settlements, bank activity, and payroll rather than accepting a single listing figure.

Prepare a bridge from reported profit to the selected earnings measure. Each adjustment should identify the account, amount, supporting record, treatment, and reason it would or would not continue. Owner compensation, financing expense, and depreciation require consistent conventions. A personal expense recorded in the business is different from an ordinary expense the buyer will still need.

Separate verified and unresolved amounts. If $18,000 of claimed cash sales lacks support, do not quietly include it in the verified column. If the statements cover eleven months, do not multiply by twelve without examining seasonality. The Restaurant Evidence Ladder defines how corroborating records strengthen a claim without turning every internal report into independent proof.

What belongs in occupancy cost?

Occupancy cost includes the contractual and operating charges necessary to control and use the location. Base rent is only the first line. Common-area charges, property-tax pass-throughs, insurance requirements, percentage rent, repairs, utilities, and required deposits can affect the actual burden.

Read the lease and amendments before calculating a percentage of sales. Identify escalations, renewal rents, landlord consent terms, and responsibility for major systems. A favorable current rent may disappear at the buyer’s required extension. An owner who also owns the property should not value restaurant earnings using unrealistically low related-party rent without explaining the adjustment.

The occupancy figure must be aligned with the transaction being considered. If the buyer intends to purchase the real estate, model property debt, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and operating-company rent separately. Use the buying guidance to investigate permitted use, control of improvements, and the conditions required for a workable assignment or new lease.

How do you calculate owner replacement cost?

Identify the work the seller performs, then price the buyer’s intended replacement plan. The number may be different for a full-time buyer, an existing operator using a shared team, and an investor hiring independent management.

List hours and duties across purchasing, preparation, service, staff management, bookkeeping, marketing, maintenance, and customer relationships. Include unpaid family contributions and tasks hidden outside normal opening hours. Avoid using one generalized manager salary to cover several distinct roles that cannot realistically be combined.

Be careful about double counting. If SDE adds back one owner’s compensation, the replacement adjustment should reflect the continuing work the buyer will not perform personally. If a competent manager’s wages are already in operating expenses and remain necessary, do not subtract the same wages again. The operations hub provides practical methods for documenting roles and testing independence from the seller.

What does cash after closing actually measure?

This number measures buyer liquidity remaining after funding the complete project, not the restaurant’s accounting profit or the seller’s net proceeds. List cash available, firm financing sources, required equity, transaction expenses, deposits, inventory, immediate capital work, and other funded uses.

Consider timing as well as totals. Legal and inspection costs may be payable before a lender disburses. A landlord deposit may be required before possession. Payroll may arrive before enough customer receipts settle. A reserve funded on paper is not helpful if it cannot be drawn when the business needs it.

The SBA 7(a) program overview identifies eligible financing categories at a general level. The current SOP index is the starting point for lender policy review. Neither source makes an individual buyer’s proposed cash contribution, reserve, or seller note automatically acceptable. Ask the lender to confirm the actual structure and uses.

What does a complete worked screen look like?

Use explicit assumptions and show the arithmetic. The following figures are illustrative planning inputs, not a real transaction, financing quote, or Illinois market benchmark.

Illustrative Four-Number Restaurant Screen
NumberAssumptionInterpretation
Verified owner benefit$208,000 annuallySupported earnings before buyer-specific management and acquisition debt
Annual occupancy cost$96,000 on $1,200,000 net sales8% of sales, subject to lease definitions and future resets
Additional owner replacement$72,000 annuallyCost required because this buyer will not perform the seller's role
Cash after project funding$62,000Liquidity remaining after identified acquisition uses

The buyer’s adjusted starting cash flow is $208,000 minus $72,000, or $136,000 before acquisition debt and other buyer changes. Occupancy is already included in the underlying earnings here; subtracting $96,000 again would be an error. Separately, the buyer must test whether $62,000 covers the operation’s exposure to slower sales or delayed opening.

The National Restaurant Association’s operating-data release helps explain why food, labor, and occupancy definitions matter. It is not a passing threshold for this example. A modeled reserve should come from the target’s obligations and risk, not a national ratio copied without context.

How do you stress-test the four numbers?

Change assumptions that could reasonably move against the buyer and identify the resulting cash requirement. Sales below expectation, higher labor expense, a major equipment repair, a rent reset, or a delayed licensing decision can each challenge a thin plan.

  1. Establish a reconciled base case with clearly defined earnings and costs.
  2. Change one material assumption at a time to understand its effect.
  3. Combine plausible adverse assumptions rather than treating risks as isolated.
  4. Compare the cash deficit and timing with accessible reserves.
  5. Identify a response: more capital, revised terms, further evidence, or withdrawal.

Do not mistake an adverse scenario for a prediction. Its purpose is to make vulnerability visible. Also avoid offsetting a known cost increase with an unsupported sales-growth assumption. A buyer can pursue growth after closing while still paying a price and carrying debt supported by the existing evidence.

How should owners use the results before selling?

Owners can use the screen to anticipate buyer questions and prioritize preparation. Weak earnings evidence suggests reconciliation work. A difficult occupancy position suggests lease planning. Heavy owner dependence suggests training and documentation. Thin buyer liquidity may require a different buyer profile or transaction structure.

Record each unresolved issue, the evidence needed, the responsible person, and a review date. Return to the screen when the operating period, lease proposal, funding plan, or buyer role changes. The benefit is a disciplined conversation: everyone can see which assumptions support the opportunity and which still need to be earned through diligence.

What else do owners and buyers ask?

Does the Four-Number Restaurant Screen tell me an asking price?

It helps identify financial and operating questions before pricing, but it does not calculate a market value. Comparable transactions, assets, lease rights, licensing, business condition, and buyer characteristics still require review. Use the screen to decide what needs investigation, then develop a valuation with explicit assumptions and supporting evidence.

Which earnings figure should I put into the screen?

Use a reconciled historical earnings measure with a written definition and adjustment schedule. For an owner-operated restaurant, SDE may be relevant, but confirm which owner compensation and other adjustments it includes. Keep unsupported add-backs outside the verified total and explain how the intended buyer's operating role changes continuing costs.

Can I use the screen for a closed restaurant space?

A closed space may have no meaningful continuing earnings, so the first number remains absent rather than being replaced with an optimistic forecast. Occupancy cost, required staffing, and remaining capital are still useful planning inputs. Assess equipment, usable improvements, approvals, and the cost of opening a new operation separately.

Is there a passing score or minimum cash reserve?

There is no universal passing score or prescribed reserve in this framework. The appropriate decision depends on the business, the buyer, seasonality, fixed costs, financing, and unresolved approvals. Record the assumptions and stress-test adverse conditions. A screen marked incomplete is more useful than false precision built on missing information.

Where can you verify the details?

Primary sources reviewed for this guide. Requirements can change; confirm the rules that apply to your address and transaction.

  1. 7(a) acquisition-financing overview — U.S. Small Business Administration
  2. Restaurant operating-cost observations — National Restaurant Association
  3. Current SOP 50 10 loan-origination policies — U.S. Small Business Administration

Return to valuation & financing

YOUR NEXT CHAPTER STARTS WITH A CONVERSATION

Let’s talk about
your restaurant.

Buying, selling, or weighing your options? Bring your questions. We’ll help you think through the next step.

Book a confidential intro call
Book a confidential intro call